On September 14, 2026, the SEC’s Division of Examinations published its observations on how registered investment advisers are conducting the annual review that the Compliance Rule has required for more than twenty years. Risk Alert: Examinations Observations Regarding Investment Adviser Annual Compliance Reviews (Sept. 14, 2026) (the “Alert”). The rule makes it unlawful to provide investment advice unless the adviser reviews, no less than annually, whether its compliance policies and procedures are adequate and whether they are actually being followed. 17 C.F.R. § 275.206(4)-7(b). The staff’s findings fall into five groups: reviews that were late or skipped, reviews with no procedure behind them, reviews that did not follow the procedure that existed, reviews that missed what the business was actually doing, and reviews whose findings were recorded and then ignored. None of these is a new obligation. Each is a way the staff has watched advisers fail an old one.
Reviews that were not annual
The staff found advisers with a review for 2021 and 2023 and none for 2022, advisers that let the interval stretch past twelve months when a chief compliance officer departed, and newly registered advisers that treated the Commission’s 2003 guidance permitting a first review within eighteen months as available to them. It is not. The eighteen-month window applied only to advisers registered when the rule took effect in October 2004. Compliance Programs of Investment Companies and Investment Advisers, Advisers Act Release No. 2204 (Dec. 17, 2003). Every adviser registering since then owes its first review within a year. Some advisers told the staff that annual compliance training or annual employee attestations were the review. They are inputs to a review, not a substitute for one. The staff also singled out advisers that had already received a deficiency letter for a missed or late review and had not corrected the practice. That is the profile the Division refers to enforcement, and the O’Malley, Walsh, and Watts guide notes that failure to conduct the annual review has been the basis for many of the Commission’s Compliance Rule cases. Thomas P. O’Malley, Kathleen M. Walsh & Sean P. Watts, Investment Adviser’s Legal and Compliance Guide § 5.01 (3d ed. 2026 Supp.).
Reviews with no procedure, or with a procedure nobody followed
Many compliance manuals state that the firm will review its program annually and will test and validate its procedures. The staff found that the sentence was often all there was. The manual did not say what tests to run, what factors to weigh in deciding whether a procedure was working, or what records to keep. Other manuals scattered review requirements across their chapters, such as an identity theft section mandating annual testing, and then omitted those topics from the annual review chapter, so the topics were never tested. Where a procedure did exist, the staff found reviews that ignored the review period it specified, skipped the workpapers it required, or tested a superseded version of the manual rather than the one in force.
The Commission’s own guidance is that an adviser first identifies the conflicts and risks particular to its business and then writes procedures to address them. The review is the test of whether that mapping still holds. The O’Malley guide describes what examiners now ask for: a current inventory of the compliance risks behind the policies and a document mapping each risk to the procedure that addresses it. Advisers that maintain that map use it to plan and record the tests that make up the review, drawing on the methods the staff has endorsed: comparing written procedures to current practice, business-unit self-assessments, interviews, forensic tests and exception reports, and follow-up on audit findings. O’Malley, Walsh & Watts, Investment Adviser’s Legal and Compliance Guide § 5.01[1].
Reviews that did not see the business
The most consequential findings are the ones the staff made by comparing the adviser’s annual review to what the adviser was actually doing. Reviews did not catch fee billing that departed from the advisory agreement and Form ADV, including unprorated fees on large mid-period deposits, breakpoints never applied, and refunds never issued on terminated accounts. Reviews did not catch proxy voting policies that promised to vote in clients’ best economic interest while the adviser told clients it did not vote and in fact did not. Reviews did not catch custody procedures that never told the surprise-examination accountant which accounts the adviser had custody of, marketing procedures never updated for the Marketing Rule that took effect in November 2022, and filing procedures that never added Form CRS after the adviser took on retail clients. Reviews also omitted compliance incidents that had been identified and reported during the year. Each is an area where the staff has published separate observations, including its Marketing Rule findings of April 2024 and December 2025, and each is a gap a review that compared the manual to the practice would have found first.
Documentation and follow-through
The Books and Records Rule requires an adviser to keep any records documenting its annual review. 17 C.F.R. § 275.204-2(a)(17)(ii). The staff found advisers whose written report discussed violations found during the review but who had discarded the testing records and corrective-action recommendations behind it, advisers whose own procedures required a written report that was never prepared, and advisers whose required checklists were left half completed. The rule does not prescribe a format. The Commission adopted an amendment in August 2023 requiring the review to be documented in writing, and the Fifth Circuit vacated it with the rest of the private fund rulemaking in June 2024. Private Fund Advisers; Documentation of Registered Investment Adviser Compliance Reviews, Advisers Act Release No. 6383 (Aug. 23, 2023), vacated, Nat’l Ass’n of Private Fund Managers v. SEC, 103 F.4th 1097 (5th Cir. 2024). What survives is the recordkeeping rule and the adviser’s own manual. If the manual promises a report, the absence of one is a deficiency under the adviser’s own standard.
The last group of findings concerns reviews that worked and were then ignored. Reviews recommended better proxy voting disclosure, documented client risk tolerances, and more thorough best execution and broker-dealer due diligence, and the adviser did none of it. In some cases the next year’s report stated the corrective action had been taken when the problem was still there. A review that identifies a deficiency and does not fix it is worse than no review, because it documents that the adviser knew. The O’Malley guide’s advice is to convert every finding into an action plan with an owner and a date and to expect the examination staff to ask for proof of what was done. O’Malley, Walsh & Watts, Investment Adviser’s Legal and Compliance Guide § 5.01[4].
What the staff expects a review to look like
The staff’s long-standing position, restated in this Alert and in the guidance both treatises rely on, is that a review runs weeks to months rather than a day, starts from a risk inventory rather than a generic checklist, tests procedures against practice rather than reading them, and almost never concludes that nothing needs to change. Investment Advisers: Law & Compliance § 14.02 (Matthew Bender 2026). An adviser preparing for its next review should fix the completion date and hold to it, write the review procedure its manual has been promising, build the risk-to-procedure map, compare the fee schedule, proxy policy, custody list, marketing procedures, and filing calendar to what the firm actually did in the review period, keep every workpaper, and close every open item from last year before opening this one.
For more information. Evans Law, PC conducts and supports annual compliance reviews for registered investment advisers, including risk inventories, testing plans, and remediation of examination findings. For an overview of the firm’s adviser practice, see our Investment Adviser Services page. To discuss your firm’s review or a deficiency letter, contact Evans Law, PC.
