Skip to main content
Contact

Updates

SEC Examination Staff Publishes Its Marketing Rule Findings on Testimonials, Endorsements, and Third-Party Ratings

Rows of round brass-rimmed keys on an antique black typewriter, on a worn wooden desk

On December 16, 2025, the SEC’s Division of Examinations issued its second set of published findings on how registered investment advisers are complying with the Marketing Rule, 17 C.F.R. § 275.206(4)-1. Risk Alert: Additional Observations Regarding Advisers’ Compliance with the Advisers Act Marketing Rule (Dec. 16, 2025) (the “December 2025 Alert”). The first set, issued April 17, 2024, covered compliance programs, recordkeeping, Form ADV, and the rule’s seven general prohibitions. Risk Alert: Initial Observations Regarding Advisers Act Marketing Rule Compliance (Apr. 17, 2024) (the “April 2024 Alert”). The new alert takes up what the first one left out: the conditions for using testimonials, endorsements, and third-party ratings. Read together, the two alerts are the examination staff’s working checklist for a marketing review. An adviser that measures its own advertising against them before the staff does will know where it stands.

The April 2024 Alert: programs on paper, deficiencies in practice

The staff found that most advisers had written Marketing Rule policies and trained their people on them. The deficiencies were in design and execution. Policies consisted of general statements of expectation rather than procedures, ignored the channels the adviser actually used, particularly websites and social media, and in some cases were updated but not followed. The staff’s example is telling: advisers whose policies required net-of-fee performance in every performance advertisement, and whose advertisements showed only gross returns. The Compliance Rule, 17 C.F.R. § 275.206(4)-7, requires policies reasonably designed to prevent violations, and the Commission has said those policies must include “objective and testable means” of doing so. Investment Adviser Marketing, Advisers Act Release No. 5653 (Dec. 22, 2020). A policy that restates the rule is not a procedure.

On recordkeeping, advisers completed the questionnaires behind third-party ratings but kept no copy, failed to retain social media posts, and could not document advertised performance. 17 C.F.R. § 275.204-2(a)(11), (16). On Form ADV, advisers reported that their advertisements contained no third-party ratings, no performance, and no hypothetical performance when their marketing materials contained all three. Others still described referral arrangements in the vocabulary of the repealed cash solicitation rule, which the O’Malley, Walsh, and Watts guide notes the staff now calls out by name. Thomas P. O’Malley, Kathleen M. Walsh & Sean P. Watts, Investment Adviser’s Legal and Compliance Guide § 2.03 (3d ed.).

The general prohibition findings are the most concrete guidance the staff has given on what “misleading” means under the rule. Advisers described themselves as “free of all conflicts” while conflicts existed, claimed a network of professionals when one person did the work, referenced ESG mandates and screening processes that did not exist, and announced awards never received. Advisers stated they were “seen on” national media without disclosing the appearances were paid, and displayed the SEC logo in ways that implied approval. Performance presentations omitted time periods, compared to undefined benchmarks, and counted realized gains in net returns while leaving out unrealized losses. The April 2024 Alert was released the same day the Commission announced its second group of Marketing Rule settlements, five advisers paying a combined $200,000, following a September 2023 group of nine advisers paying $850,000. Investment Advisers: Law & Compliance § 7.01 (Matthew Bender). The examination findings and the enforcement program are drawn from the same well.

The December 2025 Alert: testimonials and endorsements

Under the rule, a testimonial is a statement of approval from a current client or private fund investor and an endorsement is the same statement from anyone else. 17 C.F.R. § 275.206(4)-1(e)(17), (e)(5). Both are permitted in advertising only if the adviser satisfies disclosure, oversight, and written agreement conditions, and neither may be purchased from a person disqualified by a disciplinary history. The staff’s single most common finding was that the required disclosures were not delivered at the moment the testimonial or endorsement was disseminated. The rule requires three disclosures to be clear and prominent and made at that moment: whether the person is a current client, whether the person was compensated, and a brief statement of any material conflict. 17 C.F.R. § 275.206(4)-1(b)(1). The Commission said in adopting the rule that a hyperlink does not satisfy that standard and that the disclosure must be at least as prominent as the statement it accompanies. The staff found hyperlinked disclosures, disclosures in smaller or lighter type, and none at all, often on adviser websites and on the doing-business-as websites of individual representatives.

Several findings involve arrangements advisers did not recognize as endorsements. Lead-generation firms, social media influencers, referral networks, and refer-a-friend programs paid in gift cards all produce endorsements or testimonials under the rule, and the adviser is responsible for the disclosures each of them makes. The rule’s exemption for compensation of $1,000 or less applies to the total paid over the preceding twelve months, not to each payment. 17 C.F.R. § 275.206(4)-1(b)(4)(i), (e)(2). Advisers who paid a promoter less than $1,000 at a time but more than $1,000 in a year had no written agreement and no exemption. Where written agreements existed, some did not describe the scope of the promoter’s activities or the terms of compensation, the two things the rule requires an agreement to contain. Other advisers disclosed that promoters were paid but not how much or on what basis. Advisers also failed to disclose that promoters were investors in the adviser, compensated promoters disqualified by state disciplinary orders, and used affiliated promoters without disclosing the affiliation until the prospect had already been introduced, which is too late.

The December 2025 Alert: third-party ratings

An adviser may advertise a third-party rating only if it has a reasonable basis to believe the survey behind it made favorable and unfavorable responses equally easy to give and was not designed to produce a predetermined result, and only if the advertisement clearly and prominently discloses the date of the rating, the period it covers, the identity of the rater, and any compensation the adviser paid to obtain or use it. 17 C.F.R. § 275.206(4)-1(c). The staff described what compliant due diligence looked like: reviewing the rater’s published methodology, obtaining the questionnaire, or getting a representation from the rater about how the survey was structured. Advisers that did none of these had no basis for the belief the rule requires and, as the O’Malley, Walsh, and Watts guide observes, nothing in a compliance file to show an examiner. O’Malley, Walsh & Watts, Investment Adviser’s Legal and Compliance Guide § 2.05[C].

The disclosure findings follow the same pattern as the testimonial findings. Advertisements listed a range of award years that included a year in which the adviser received no award. Rating logos did not identify the rater. Advisers paid for logo licenses, reprints, priority placement, or referral links on the rater’s site, or paid simply to be considered for the rating, and disclosed none of it. Disclosures that did exist were hyperlinked, shrunk, or moved to the bottom of the page away from the rating they described.

What advisers should do now

Inventory every place the firm and its representatives appear, including each representative’s doing-business-as site and any third-party site the firm links to or pays. For each testimonial, endorsement, or rating found, confirm the clear-and-prominent disclosures sit with the statement, in type no smaller than the statement, with no hyperlink between them. Identify every person the adviser pays for referrals in cash or in kind, total the payments over the trailing twelve months, and put a written agreement stating scope and compensation in place with each promoter above $1,000. Obtain and file the methodology or a written representation for every rating in use. Reconcile Form ADV Part 1A, Item 5.L and Part 2A, Item 14 against what the advertisements actually contain. Then rewrite the marketing procedures so that each step is a named task with a named owner and a review date. The staff’s observation across both alerts is that written policies existed and were not followed. A procedure that cannot be tested is not one the staff will credit.

For more information. Evans Law, PC advises registered investment advisers on Marketing Rule compliance, promoter agreements, and examination preparation and response. For an overview of the firm’s adviser practice, see our Investment Adviser Services page. To discuss a marketing review or a pending examination, contact Evans Law, PC.

This update is general information about a regulatory development, not legal advice, and reading it creates no attorney-client relationship. Whether it applies to you depends on facts it cannot know. See our Attorney Advertising, Legal Notices & Disclaimers.

All updates

Does this affect your firm?

We would appreciate hearing from you.

Contact the firm