Practice Areas › Securities Investigations and Enforcement
Wells Notices
A Wells notice means the staff has already decided, preliminarily, to recommend charges. It is not the start of an investigation. It is close to the end of one.
What it is
Notice that charges are coming — and a chance to argue before they do.
A Wells notice tells you that enforcement staff has made a preliminary determination to recommend an action, and identifies the conduct and provisions at issue. It invites a voluntary written response — a Wells submission — before the recommendation goes forward.
It is not only an SEC instrument. That is the most common misunderstanding about it. FINRA uses the same process in its disciplinary matters, and state securities regulators and certain other agencies use an equivalent step. The mechanics and the internal review differ; the position you are in does not.
One practical difference worth knowing: FINRA staff will sometimes raise it informally first, by telephone, before anything arrives in writing. A call that sounds like a courtesy may be the beginning of this, and it should be treated as such.
By the time it arrives, the documents have been produced, the testimony has been taken, and the staff has formed a view. The submission is an opportunity to change that view — not an opportunity to start explaining the facts for the first time.
The decision
Whether to make a submission at all.
This is the question the page exists to frame. A Wells submission is voluntary, and making one is not automatically the right answer.
What it can do for you
It is the last chance to persuade before charges are public. Submissions do result in matters being closed, in charges being narrowed, and in claims being dropped that the staff had misread. Senior staff review them, and at FINRA a separate office reviews them before a complaint is authorized. The audience is real.
What it can cost you
A submission is a written statement by the person under investigation. It can be used against them. It commits you to a version of events before you have seen the full case, and it shows the staff your defenses in time for them to be answered. A weak submission does not leave you where you started — it leaves you worse off.
And the parallel-proceeding problem
Where there is a related criminal inquiry, a private lawsuit or an arbitration, a submission written for the regulator does not stay with the regulator. That possibility changes the calculation completely, and it is the first thing to establish before anything is drafted.
The realistic outcomes
Matters close with no action. Charges get narrowed. Most resolve by negotiated settlement rather than a contested proceeding. Some proceed as filed. The submission is one input into which of those happens — an important one, and not the only one.
Traps
Where this goes wrong.
Treating the deadline as the constraint
The window is usually short — commonly around 30 days — and extensions are often available for good reason. Rushing a submission to meet the first date given is a poor trade when the document will be read closely and quoted later.
Arguing the facts when the problem is the law, or the reverse
Some matters turn on what happened. Others turn on whether what happened violates anything. A submission that relitigates agreed facts when the real dispute is legal — or asserts a legal theory when the staff simply has the chronology wrong — spends the one shot on the wrong argument.
Assuming firm counsel is your counsel
A firm and an individual receiving related notices may start aligned and end opposed. The firm can settle in a way that resolves its exposure and leaves the individual's intact. That divergence tends to appear late, and separate counsel is easier to arrange early than mid-submission.
Overlooking what has to be disclosed
For a public company, a Wells notice can raise disclosure questions of its own. For a registered person, the eventual outcome may be reportable. The regulatory question and the disclosure question run on separate tracks and need answering together.
This page is general information, not legal or tax advice. How it applies depends on facts this page cannot know, and the rules change. Reading it creates no attorney-client relationship. Please see our Attorney Advertising, Legal Notices & Disclaimers.
Received a Wells notice?
The decision about whether to respond at all is worth making deliberately, and early.
Contact the firm