Skip to main content
Contact

Updates

Supreme Court Holds the SEC Need Not Prove Investor Losses to Obtain Disgorgement

Rows of round brass-rimmed keys on an antique black typewriter, on a worn wooden desk

On June 4, 2026, a unanimous Supreme Court held that the Securities and Exchange Commission need not show that investors suffered a financial loss before a court may order a defendant to disgorge the profits of a securities violation. Sripetch v. SEC, 608 U.S. ___, No. 25-466 (June 4, 2026). Justice Gorsuch wrote for the Court; Justice Thomas concurred separately. The decision closes one defense to disgorgement and expressly leaves several others open, including the question that matters most in practice: what happens when the Commission cannot return the money to anyone.

The holding rests on what equity requires, not on what the Exchange Act says

The Commission sued Ongkaruck Sripetch over pump-and-dump schemes involving at least twenty penny-stock companies. He consented to judgment and agreed the court could order disgorgement, then opposed the Commission’s request for more than $4.1 million on the ground that it had no evidence any investor lost money.

The Court rejected the argument on equitable grounds rather than statutory ones. A person seeking restitution of a wrongdoer’s gain has never had to prove a corresponding loss, or any loss. Where a defendant has invaded a protected interest, the remedy strips the gain from that invasion; it does not measure the claimant’s damage. Liu v. SEC, 591 U.S. 71 (2020), required that disgorgement be awarded for victims, but the Court held that requirement came from equity, and equity does not make pecuniary loss a condition of being a victim.

The Court also answered the argument that disgorgement must restore the status quo. When a defendant enriches himself without leaving anyone financially worse off, a court must choose between two status quos — strip the wrongdoer of his gains, or let him keep them. Equity prefers the first.

Notably, the Court assumed without deciding that disgorgement under 15 U.S.C. § 78u(d)(7), the provision Congress added after Liu, remains an equitable remedy governed by traditional equitable rules. It did not decide whether that section expanded the Commission’s authority.

Govil is abrogated

The decision resolves a split. The Second Circuit had read Liu to require a showing of pecuniary harm. SEC v. Govil, 86 F.4th 89 (2d Cir. 2023). The First and Ninth Circuits disagreed, the Ninth in the decision now affirmed. SEC v. Navellier & Assocs., 108 F.4th 19, 27 (1st Cir. 2024); SEC v. Sripetch, 154 F.4th 980 (9th Cir. 2025). Defendants in the Second Circuit lose an argument that had real value there for three years.

What the Court expressly did not decide

More was reserved than resolved, and each reservation is a defense worth preserving.

Whether the Commission may obtain disgorgement when distributing the funds to investors is infeasible. Liu left this open in 2020 and Sripetch leaves it open now, along with what showing of infeasibility the Commission would have to make. This is the live question in most contested disgorgement fights.

Whether Section 78u(d)(7) permits departure from equitable principles. The Court said that if the Commission used that provision to seek penalties for the Treasury rather than compensation for victims, it would move beyond what Liu tolerated under Section 78u(d)(5), and that such a step would raise further questions — citing SEC v. Jarkesy, 603 U.S. 109 (2024), which held that the Seventh Amendment entitles a defendant to a jury when the Commission seeks penalties. That sentence is an invitation.

Whether disgorgement reaches violations that invade no investor’s legally protected interest. Amici raised it; the Court set it aside because Sripetch never disputed that his victims’ protected interests were invaded. A defendant who does dispute it has preserved ground.

Justice Thomas would go further

Justice Thomas concurred to say that disgorgement is not a traditional equitable remedy at all, that its lineage runs to lower court decisions of the 1970s rather than to historical equity practice, and that by separating disgorgement into its own subsection with its own limitations period Congress made it a legal remedy. His conclusion is that in a future case the Court should hold that Section 78u(d)(7) disgorgement carries a Seventh Amendment jury trial right.

No other Justice joined him. But a concurrence identifying the argument it wants presented is a roadmap, and defense counsel should read it as one.

Why the Commission’s win may be narrower than it looks

The pecuniary-harm problem and the distribution problem tend to arise in the same cases. Where the economic effect of a violation is diffuse enough that harm is hard to prove, identifying who should receive the money is usually hard for the same reason. Commentators have noted the scale of the gap: disgorgement ordered over the past five years approaches $25 billion, while roughly $3 billion has been returned to harmed investors. Much of that difference is collection failure rather than policy, but not all of it.

Sripetch removes the requirement to prove loss. It does not remove Liu’s requirement that disgorgement be awarded for victims. A defendant facing a disgorgement demand should still ask how the Commission proposes to distribute what it collects, and should not treat that question as foreclosed.

One further wrinkle for anyone briefing this area: neither the Ninth Circuit nor the Supreme Court mentioned Ciminelli v. United States, 598 U.S. 306 (2023), which held that the federal fraud statutes reach only traditional property interests. Commentators have argued the two decisions sit uneasily together. The point is unresolved rather than settled against the defense.

For investors

If you lost money in a fraud the Commission has charged, this decision makes it easier for the Commission to take the wrongdoer’s profits away from him. It does not change how, or whether, that money reaches you. Disgorgement collected by the Commission is distributed through a separate process that often takes years, frequently returns less than the amount ordered, and depends on the Commission being able to identify affected investors and reach them. Keep your trade confirmations and account statements, watch for notices from a claims administrator in any Commission action affecting a security you held, and respond to claim deadlines when they come. A missed deadline is one of the common reasons ordered funds are never returned.

For more information. If you have questions about a Commission disgorgement demand, the measure of an award, or how Sripetch affects a pending enforcement matter, contact Evans Law, PC.

This update is general information about a regulatory development, not legal advice, and reading it creates no attorney-client relationship. Whether it applies to you depends on facts it cannot know. See our Attorney Advertising, Legal Notices & Disclaimers.

All updates

Does this affect your firm?

We would appreciate hearing from you.

Contact the firm